Living room · Sony 75" · Yamaha RX-V683

Four devices, one wire, no referee.

HDMI-CEC lets any device shout “switch to me” down the same cable. Nothing acknowledges, nothing retries, and the loudest voice at that instant wins. Here's what that looks like, and what we did about it.

Yamaha RX-V683standby
— — —
press play to watch the race
Cold start from the Fire TV remote

Who's on the bus

Everything behind the receiver arrives at the TV on one port, so the TV can't tell these apart. Four CEC-capable devices, all able to claim the screen.

AVR HDMI 3 Fire TV Stick 4KThe one we actually use claims input
AVR HDMI 2 Apple TVOccasional use, older model claims input
TV HDMI 2 PlayStationWired straight to the TV, skips the receiver claims input
TV HDMI 3 Yamaha RX-V683Also broadcasts its own ARC request on wake obeys + asks
— Nintendo SwitchNo CEC. Never part of the problem. silent

The failure, precisely

On wake the Sony broadcasts “send me TV audio,” which pushes the receiver to its ARC input — AUDIO1. That message often lands after the Fire TV's request, so it overwrites it. The receiver sits on AUDIO1 showing its own idle screen. Ten to fifteen seconds later the Fire TV's claim finally gets through and the input corrects itself. Nothing is broken; two requests simply arrived in the wrong order.

The fix: stop relying on the shouting

The Fire TV remote has its own infrared emitter. Infrared is one-way and dumb, which here is the entire point — it sends “power on” and “HDMI 3” as specific codes, with no bus to lose them on. We gave the receiver a second, independent path.

Fire TV → Settings → Equipment Control → Receiver
Power ControlThe master switch. Nothing else here works while it's off.On
Power CommandSeparate on and off codes instead of one toggle that can guess wrongDiscrete On/Off
Power Command RepetitionOnce
Power On DelaySettle time before the input code is sent7 seconds
Receiver inputSet during setup — the physical port the Stick is inHDMI 3
Fire TV → Settings → Equipment Control → Fire TV
Input modeThe one that stopped it hijacking the screen mid-show. On Automatic it kept reclaiming the input while the Apple TV was playing.Manual
Fire TV → Settings → Equipment Control → TV
Power CommandDiscrete On/Off
Power On Delay6 seconds
Input Change TypeNo discrete option exists for this Sony — it counts arrow presses down a list. Left alone; the TV stays on HDMI 3 anyway.Navigate Up + Down
Left deliberately on
Fire TV → Display & Sounds → HDMI CEC Device ControlStill what wakes the Sony. Infrared covers the receiver; CEC covers the TV. Both paths running together is why it works.On
Yamaha → HDMI → HDMI Control / Standby ThroughOn / On

House rules

Two habits cover almost everything.

Start with the Fire TV remote — always
It's the only remote wired to the infrared path. Waking the system with the Sony or Yamaha remote instead drops you back onto CEC alone, which is the slow, unreliable route. Same buttons, very different reliability.
For the Apple TV, use its own remote and the Yamaha's
Turn the Apple TV on manually and switch the receiver to HDMI 2. Don't touch the Fire TV remote while you're on it — any button press fires “power on, go to HDMI 3” and pulls you straight back.
Give a cold start about ten seconds
Power on delays are set to 6 and 7 seconds on purpose. A pause before anything visible happens is the system working, not failing. Pressing more buttons during that window makes it worse.

If something misbehaves

Receiver sits on AUDIO1 and doesn't move
Wait fifteen seconds before touching anything — the correction usually arrives on its own. If it becomes routine, raise Power On Delay on the Receiver entry to 15–18 seconds so the infrared command fires after the CEC traffic settles.
Screen jumps back to Fire TV on its own
Check Equipment Control → Fire TV is still on Manual. On Automatic it reasserts itself constantly.
Receiver turns on then immediately off
Both paths fired and cancelled each other. Turn off HDMI CEC Device Control on the Fire TV. Infrared alone handles power and input; the trade is that the TV may stop waking by itself.
Nothing wakes at all after a power cut
Unplug the TV, receiver and Fire TV at the wall for five minutes, then power on in order: receiver, TV, Fire TV. That forces every device to re-register its address on the bus.
You want it genuinely deterministic
The RX-V683 is on the network and answers HTTP. A single request to its YamahaExtendedControl endpoint sets the input every time, with no infrared and no CEC involved. That's the real fix whenever it's worth an evening.